i agree completely...
a good example would be: if you were to rob a bank, knowing that they have three security guards, it would be difficulty if not impossible. however if you were to wait till they went to lunch then it wouldnt matter if they had 300 guards, because if they arent there at the time of the robbery, they wont effect it!
all that changing it would actually change is the power at the time...it might cause you to show less power now, but if your members become active again, you power will go right back up... your not loosing anything, its just making the list more acurate
a good example would be: if you were to rob a bank, knowing that they have three security guards, it would be difficulty if not impossible. however if you were to wait till they went to lunch then it wouldnt matter if they had 300 guards, because if they arent there at the time of the robbery, they wont effect it!
all that changing it would actually change is the power at the time...it might cause you to show less power now, but if your members become active again, you power will go right back up... your not loosing anything, its just making the list more acurate
Quote
Except the fact that they are still a part of the guild, regardless of not logging in for 3 days 
It's just an easy way to make it so that weaker, undeserving guilds can defeat the guilds that are way out of their true power range. Sure, it makes the Guild Vs. Guild raid system more dynamic, but it also takes away from the sense of progression within the system itself.
It's just an easy way to make it so that weaker, undeserving guilds can defeat the guilds that are way out of their true power range. Sure, it makes the Guild Vs. Guild raid system more dynamic, but it also takes away from the sense of progression within the system itself.
Personally if you are outside of the 72 hour comfort zone then you are still able to gain full advantage of the high powered help within the guild during attacking and defending situations.
Th entire guild raid system will be thrown wide open if the 72 hour rule is to be implemented and I for one would look forward to it as I am the main starter and setter off of all of our raids
Thats a good point, Sociopath! The guild still benefits from active members helping during attack.
Well, I'm happy now. Something to stir things up a bit, and still a reason for the 28 inactivity of guild members.
I'll see about getting it implemented. Should only require the changing of the power formula - hopefully I've been clever and put it in one function, rather than pasting it like a lazy moron. I used to do that a lot. Kills you when you have to edit stuff.
This version is very neat though
Well, I'm happy now. Something to stir things up a bit, and still a reason for the 28 inactivity of guild members.
I'll see about getting it implemented. Should only require the changing of the power formula - hopefully I've been clever and put it in one function, rather than pasting it like a lazy moron. I used to do that a lot. Kills you when you have to edit stuff.
This version is very neat though
Invisible War ][
Deleted Player
Christ, talk about missing the point 
Not you Cyber though
Not you Cyber though